Shareholder Letters: Accounting Themes

Growing earnings, negative free cash flow

Amazon letters: 2004

Jaeyoon Yu, Ph.D.
Central Michigan University

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow1 / 8
What the Letter Says

“Though some may find it counterintuitive, a company can actually impair shareholder value in certain circumstances by growing earnings.”

Jeffrey P. Bezos, 2004 letter

  • Key letters: 2004
  • Course fit: ACC250 Ch9 · ACC531 Analytics · Difficulty: Intermediate
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow2 / 8
Step 1: Earnings Double Every Year

Bezos’s example: a business buys machines to grow ($ thousands).

Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4
Sales100,000200,000400,000800,000
Depreciation(40,000)(80,000)(160,000)(320,000)
Earnings10,00020,00040,00080,000
  • Earnings growth: 100% a year. Investors would be delighted.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow3 / 8
Step 2: Add Back Depreciation
Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4
Earnings10,00020,00040,00080,000
+ Depreciation40,00080,000160,000320,000
Operating cash flow50,000100,000200,000400,000
  • No change in working capital in the example, so operating cash flow = earnings + depreciation.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow4 / 8
Step 3: Subtract Capital Expenditures
Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4
Operating cash flow50,000100,000200,000400,000
− Capital expenditures(160,000)(160,000)(320,000)(640,000)
Free cash flow(110,000)(60,000)(120,000)(240,000)
  • New machines are paid for up front; their cost reaches earnings only slowly.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow5 / 8
Back to the Letter
  • Bezos (2004): a company can hurt shareholder value by growing earnings.
  • Same example with EBITDA: $50, $100, $200, $400 million → “EBITDA isn’t cash flow.”
  • Over four years the business has negative free cash flow of $530 million.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow6 / 8
Questions
  1. In Bezos’s example (in thousands), Year 1 earnings are $10,000, depreciation is $40,000 and there is no working capital change. Capital expenditures are $160,000. What is free cash flow (operating cash flow − capital expenditures; use a minus sign if negative)?
  2. In the example, earnings double every year while free cash flow is negative every year. Why?
    1. Revenue is recorded before it is earned
    2. Depreciation is paid in cash each year
    3. The business pays no income taxes
    4. The business pays cash for new machines up front, more than its operating cash flow, while depreciation spreads their cost over many years
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow7 / 8
Sources

Letters © Amazon.com, Inc.; quoted for non-commercial teaching. Examples use made-up numbers unless a slide says otherwise. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Amazon.com, Inc.

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesGrowing earnings, negative free cash flow8 / 8