Shareholder Letters: Accounting Themes

Purchase vs. pooling for acquisitions

Berkshire letters: 1999, 2000

Jaeyoon Yu, Ph.D.
Central Michigan University

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions1 / 8
What the Letter Says

“Managements usually detest purchase accounting because it almost always requires that a “goodwill” account be established and subsequently written off.”

Warren E. Buffett, 1999 letter

  • Key letters: 1999, 2000
  • Course fit: ACC250 — · ACC531 — · Difficulty: Advanced
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions2 / 8
Step 1: Same Deal, Two Methods (before 2001)

EX. Pay $500 for a company; book value of its net assets $300; fair value $380.

PurchasePooling
Net assets recorded atFair value $380Book value $300
Goodwill$120$0
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions3 / 8
Step 2: The Effect on Later Earnings
  • Before 2002, goodwill was amortized (up to 40 years).
Each yearPurchasePooling
Goodwill amortization$3$0
  • Purchase method → lower reported earnings every year; pooling → none.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions4 / 8
Step 3: Today
  • SFAS 141 (2001) banned pooling: only the acquisition (purchase) method is allowed.
  • SFAS 142 (2001) ended goodwill amortization; goodwill is tested for impairment instead.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions5 / 8
Back to the Letter
  • Buffett (1999): managers “detest purchase accounting” because it creates goodwill that is written off.
  • The economics of the deal are the same under both methods; only the accounting differs.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions6 / 8
Questions
  1. Which method must U.S. companies use today to record an acquisition?
    1. The acquisition (purchase) method: assets and liabilities at fair value, the excess as goodwill
    2. Pooling of interests
    3. Either method, at management’s choice
    4. No entry until the target is sold
  2. Why did many managers prefer pooling?
    1. It recorded assets at fair value
    2. No goodwill was created, so there was no later charge against earnings
    3. It required more disclosure
    4. It raised income taxes
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions7 / 8
Sources

Letters © Berkshire Hathaway Inc.; quoted for non-commercial teaching. Examples use made-up numbers unless a slide says otherwise. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Berkshire Hathaway Inc.

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPurchase vs. pooling for acquisitions8 / 8