Shareholder Letters: Accounting Themes

Pension return assumptions

Berkshire letters: 2007, 2016

Jaeyoon Yu, Ph.D.
Central Michigan University

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions1 / 8
What the Letter Says

“Other accounting choices remain – important among these the investment-return assumption a company uses in calculating pension expense.”

Warren E. Buffett, 2007 letter

  • Key letters: 2007, 2016
  • Course fit: ACC250 — · ACC531 Estimates · Difficulty: Advanced
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions2 / 8
Step 1: What Pension Expense Includes
  • Pension expense = cost of benefits earned this year + interest on the obligation − expected return on plan assets.
  • The expected return is an assumption chosen by management.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions3 / 8
Step 2: Change the Assumption

EX. Plan assets $1,000 million.

Assumed returnExpected returnEffect on pension expense
5%$50Mreduces expense by $50M
8%$80Mreduces expense by $80M
  • 8% instead of 5% → expense $30 million lower, earnings higher. Nothing real changed.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions4 / 8
Step 3: Is the Assumption Reasonable?
  • Compare it with the plan’s asset mix: bonds and cash cannot earn 8%.
  • Auditors (ACC531): an estimate → test management’s assumptions.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions5 / 8
Back to the Letter
  • Buffett (2007): the average S&P 500 company assumed about 8% in 2006.
  • About 28% of pension assets were bonds and cash, which could be expected to return no more than 5%.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions6 / 8
Questions
  1. Pension plan assets are $1,000 million. If the company assumes an 8% expected return instead of 5%, by how much does reported pension expense fall ($ millions)?
  2. A higher assumed return on pension assets…
    1. increases the cash paid to retirees
    2. lowers pension expense and raises reported earnings
    3. raises pension expense
    4. has no effect on earnings
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions7 / 8
Sources

Letters © Berkshire Hathaway Inc.; quoted for non-commercial teaching. Examples use made-up numbers unless a slide says otherwise. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Berkshire Hathaway Inc.

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesPension return assumptions8 / 8