Shareholder Letters: Accounting Themes

Audit committees and auditors

Berkshire letters: 2002, 1998

Jaeyoon Yu, Ph.D.
Central Michigan University

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors1 / 8
What the Letter Says

“Audit committees can’t audit. ... The key job of the audit committee is simply to get the auditors to divulge what they know.”

Warren E. Buffett, 2002 letter

  • Key letters: 2002, 1998
  • Course fit: ACC250 — · ACC531 Governance · Difficulty: Intermediate
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors2 / 8
Step 1: Who Does What
PartyRole
ManagementPrepares the financial statements
External auditorGives an opinion on them
Audit committee (board)Appoints and oversees the auditor (SOX 2002)
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors3 / 8
Step 2: Buffett’s Four Questions (1)
  1. If the auditor were solely responsible for preparing the statements, would they have been prepared differently from management’s way?
  2. If the auditor were an investor, would he have received, in plain English, the information essential to understanding the company’s performance?
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors4 / 8
Step 3: Buffett’s Four Questions (2)
  1. Is the company following the same internal audit procedure that would be followed if the auditor himself were CEO?
  2. Is the auditor aware of any actions that moved revenues or expenses from one reporting period to another?
  • Ask them at least a week before the earnings release.
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors5 / 8
Back to the Letter
  • Buffett (2002): “Audit committees can’t audit.”
  • Their key job: get the auditors to divulge what they know.
  • Buffett (1998): “at times I have been amazed by the numbers that big-name auditors have implicitly blessed.”
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors6 / 8
Questions
  1. Under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, who appoints and oversees a public company’s external auditor?
    1. The audit committee of the board
    2. The CEO
    3. The CFO
    4. The SEC
  2. Buffett suggests the audit committee ask the auditor whether the financial statements would differ if the auditor had prepared them alone. What is the main purpose of such questions?
    1. To prepare the tax return
    2. To make auditors share their concerns about management’s accounting choices
    3. To lower the audit fee
    4. To replace the internal audit function
Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors7 / 8
Sources

Letters © Berkshire Hathaway Inc.; quoted for non-commercial teaching. Examples use made-up numbers unless a slide says otherwise. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Berkshire Hathaway Inc.

Shareholder Letters: Accounting ThemesAudit committees and auditors8 / 8